(Image credit: Getty Images)
For many people, investing in the stock market feels like the default path to building long-term wealth.
The potential upside is real. History shows that stocks have rewarded patient investors who can weather volatility and stay invested through downturns.
But not everyone wants to ride out those swings, and not everyone should.
Sign up for Kiplinger’s Free Newsletters
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice on investing, taxes, retirement, personal finance and more – straight to your e-mail.
Profit and prosper with the best of expert advice – straight to your e-mail.
There are moments in life when protecting what you have matters more than chasing what you hope to gain. This is where insurance-based options, such as fixed annuities or fixed indexed annuities, can play a meaningful role.
These products do not replace investing and are not meant to. Instead, they offer an alternative for people who value stability, predictable income or principal protection during uncertain times.
Knowing when to participate in the market and when to step aside is one of the most important decisions in retirement strategy. The right choice depends on your goals, your time horizon and your tolerance for loss.
The appeal of investing
The stock market offers the potential for long-term growth that outpaces inflation. For people with decades before retirement, regular contributions and time in the market can create meaningful opportunities.
Even for retirees, a portion of assets in equities may help portfolios grow enough to support longer lifespans and rising expenses.
The challenge comes with volatility. Markets move quickly. News cycles accelerate emotions. Economic shifts can create sudden declines that take years to recover from. Growth potential works in your favor over the long run, but only if you can stay invested through periods of discomfort.
That is a big “if.” Many people discover that they are less comfortable with risk than they expected once the market drops and the headlines turn negative. Selling during a downturn can lock in losses that are difficult, if not impossible, to make up later.
The need for safety
As people approach retirement or transition into more income-focused stages of life, the tolerance for market swings tends to shrink. A major downturn early in retirement can threaten the sustainability of a portfolio, especially if withdrawals occur at the same time.
This is where safe-return options can provide structure. Products like multi-year guaranteed annuities (MYGAs) or fixed indexed annuities (FIAs) are built for people who want protection rather than participation. These options:
- Protect principal from market loss
- Offer predictable interest or index-linked earnings
- Provide opportunities for lifetime income
- Reduce emotional decision-making during market volatility
They are not designed to beat the market. Their purpose is to create a stable foundation so you are not overly dependent on investments for every part of your retirement strategy.
When it makes sense to consider stepping aside
You do not need to avoid the market entirely to benefit from safe returns. The question is not “stocks or safety,” but rather “how much risk makes sense for your situation?”
Here are times when insurance-based fixed or indexed options may be a better fit.
You are within five to 10 years of retirement. Market losses late in your working years can derail retirement timing. If you cannot afford a major setback, shifting a portion of assets to principal-protected options can help secure the foundation you are building.
You need predictable income. If you want part of your retirement income guaranteed, annuities can help create a stable cash flow without relying on market performance. This gives you the confidence to let other investments pursue growth.
You are risk-averse or feel anxious during market swings. Investing should not feel like a constant emotional battle. If volatility makes you uncomfortable or causes reactive decisions, safety-oriented products can help remove stress from the equation.
You have savings you cannot afford to lose. Some dollars are “must-have” funds. This might include emergency savings, future income needs or legacy assets you want protected. Market-linked products with no downside exposure can help preserve these dollars.
You want diversification beyond traditional investments. Diversification is not only about owning different investments. It is also about combining assets that behave differently. Fixed and indexed annuities do not move with the market, which can bring balance to a portfolio.
Why the balance matters
Safe returns alone rarely generate the long-term growth needed to outpace inflation. Market growth alone may expose you to unnecessary risk at the wrong time. Most people benefit from a blend of the two.
The goal is not to guess what the market will do next. The goal is to match your strategy with your comfort level and your timeline. People who enter retirement with a mix of protected income and growth potential often feel more confident about their ability to handle both opportunities and challenges.
Insurance-based products play a supporting role by offering stability where you need it most. This lets your investment assets work more efficiently, since you are not forced to sell in a downturn or take more risk than you want.
How to decide what is right for you
If you are unsure whether the market is right for you right now, consider taking the following steps:
Review your time horizon. Shorter timelines call for more protection. Longer timelines offer more room for growth.
Identify the dollars you need to protect. Determine which assets must remain stable and which can pursue higher returns.
Evaluate your emotional tolerance for loss. If volatility disrupts your confidence or decision-making, build a stronger safety net.
Consider your income needs in retirement. Guaranteed income sources can reduce pressure on the rest of your assets.
Talk with a financial professional who understands both sides of the equation. An insurance-licensed professional can help you explore options that protect principal and provide income, while coordinating with your broader strategy.
The market can be a powerful engine for long-term growth, but it is not the only tool available. There are times when stepping aside and relying on safe returns is not just wise but necessary.
When you know your comfort level and your goals, you can build a balanced approach that protects your present while still preparing for your future.